Defonte’s Menu: The Ultimate Guide to Brooklyn’s Best Sandwich Shop

When it comes to iconic sandwich shops in Brooklyn, Defonte’s menu stands out as a legendary institution. Established in 1922, this family-owned eatery has been serving locals and visitors alike for almost a century. Known for its generous portions, authentic Italian-style sandwiches, and welcoming neighborhood vibe, Defonte’s has rightfully earned a reputation as one of the best sandwich shops in Brooklyn.

A Rich History of Flavor

Defonte’s menu started as a small Italian deli in Red Hook, Brooklyn, and over the decades, it has grown into a must-visit culinary landmark. The shop has preserved its old-school charm, with a no-frills atmosphere that lets the food speak for itself. Walking into Defonte’s is like stepping back in time: walls adorned with vintage photos, a bustling counter, and the irresistible aroma of fresh meats, cheeses, and bread.

Menu Highlights: Sandwiches You Can’t Miss

Defonte’s menu is packed with classic Italian sandwiches that appeal to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters. Here are some must-try options:

• The Roast Beef Sandwich – Piled high with thinly sliced roast beef, sharp provolone, and a touch of oil and vinegar, this sandwich is a true meat lover’s dream.

• The Italian Hero – Featuring Genoa salami, ham, cappicola, and provolone, topped with lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing, it’s a timeless choice.

• The Famous Tuna – Not your ordinary tuna sandwich, Defonte’s adds a special blend of seasonings, creating a creamy and flavorful masterpiece.

• The Hot Pastrami – Slow-cooked and perfectly seasoned, served with mustard on freshly baked bread, it’s a sandwich that keeps customers coming back.

Each sandwich is served on freshly baked rolls, with generous portions of high-quality meats and cheeses. The combination of fresh ingredients and traditional recipes makes every bite unforgettable.

Why Defonte’s is Brooklyn’s Best

1. Authenticity: Defonte’s maintains old-school Italian deli traditions, making it a genuine taste of Brooklyn’s culinary history.

2. Quality Ingredients: Only the freshest meats, cheeses, and produce make it onto the sandwiches, ensuring every bite is packed with flavor.

3. Generous Portions: If you leave Defonte’s hungry, you’re doing it wrong. The sandwiches are famously large, perfect for sharing—or not.

4. Neighborhood Charm: The Red Hook location exudes a friendly, welcoming vibe that keeps locals loyal and tourists intrigued.

5. Longevity: Being in business for over 100 years is a testament to their consistency and dedication to quality.

Insider Tips for Visiting

• Go early: Sandwiches sell fast, especially on weekends.

• Bring cash: While they accept cards, cash is always appreciated.

• Ask for recommendations: The staff knows the menu inside out and can help you discover hidden gems.

• Try a classic combo: Pair your sandwich with a bag of potato chips or a soda for the full experience.

If you’re searching for an authentic, mouthwatering sandwich in Brooklyn, Defonte’s is the place to be. Its long history, unbeatable sandwiches, and neighborhood charm make it not just a meal, but an experience. Whether you’re a local or visiting New York City, a trip to Defonte’s is a culinary journey you won’t forget.